Calls for a “staggered” age of consent have returned to the headlines following recent cases involving Russell Brand and allegations concerning David Walliams. The proposal is intended to give 16- and 17-year-olds greater protection from sexual relationships with significantly older adults.
The law has not changed. The Government has said the proposal deserves consideration and scrutiny, but that is not the same as announcing a new offence or a timetable for legislation.
What is the age of consent now?
In England and Wales, the age of consent is 16. A person aged 16 or 17 can generally consent to sexual activity, and the law does not currently make a relationship unlawful solely because the other person is much older.
There are important exceptions. Sexual activity with a 16- or 17-year-old can be an offence where the adult is in a position of trust, such as a teacher or care worker. Other offences may apply where there is coercion, exploitation or a lack of consent. As the Crown Prosecution Service explains, consent must be given by choice, with the freedom and capacity to make that choice. A 16- or 17-year-old is still a child for safeguarding purposes.
What would a staggered age of consent mean?
A staggered law would make the age difference between the people involved relevant. Under the campaign proposal, sexual activity with a 16- or 17-year-old would be an offence where the older person is over a specified age and the gap between them exceeds a set number of years. The campaign says its aim is to protect teenagers from significantly older adults while preserving relationships between people close in age.
The details matter. Any new law would need to define the age threshold and age gap clearly, and explain how it would protect young people without criminalising consensual relationships between teenagers.
Why has the proposal attracted attention?
The debate has been sharpened by high-profile cases in which fame, status and age differences have featured.
Russell Brand has been convicted of rape and sexual assault offences against women who gave evidence at his trial. Separately, Mia Latter has spoken publicly about an alleged relationship with Brand when she was 16 and he was 30. Her allegation was not part of the trial, and the police investigation into it is separate. Brand has denied allegations against him.
David Walliams has also faced serious allegations reported by the media, including allegations concerning teenage girls. He denies wrongdoing, and the allegations have not been established by a court. These cases raise wider questions about how celebrity, influence and age differences can affect a young person’s ability to make choices freely.
We have written about the issues raised by these cases in our articles on celebrity sexual abuse, power and the right to claim compensation, the Russell Brand conviction and sexual abuse in the entertainment industry and the David Walliams allegations and victims’ rights. We also act for people seeking advice about claims connected with alleged abuse by Mohamed Al Fayed at Harrods and Fulham Football Club.
The questions that need to be addressed
Supporters say that the law should recognise the power imbalance that can exist between a teenager and a much older adult. A clear age-gap rule could place responsibility on the older person and make it easier to recognise relationships that carry a serious risk of exploitation.
Others warn that a change must be designed carefully. Young people need to be able to seek confidential advice and healthcare without fearing that they or a partner close to their age will be criminalised. A change in the law would also need to sit alongside effective safeguarding, education and support for anyone experiencing abuse.
A new offence would not, by itself, prevent grooming or remove the power imbalances that can arise through wealth, status, employment or celebrity. But the current debate asks an important question: does the law give enough protection to 16- and 17-year-olds when the other person is considerably older?

Help after sexual abuse
A criminal prosecution is not the only possible route to accountability. Depending on the circumstances, a survivor may be able to pursue a civil claim for compensation, including for psychological injury and financial losses. The law and time limits can be complex, particularly where abuse happened years ago.
Compensation:
The effects of sexual abuse can be profound and long-lasting. Some survivors experience serious psychological distress and find it difficult to form or maintain relationships; others may struggle to continue working or be unable to work at all. Where the evidence supports it, a compensation claim may take account of psychiatric injury, the impact on daily life and relationships, treatment costs, and past or future loss of earnings. These losses can place a considerable financial burden on a survivor, at a time when they may already be coping with the consequences of the abuse. You can read more about claiming compensation for sexual abuse.
If you have experienced sexual abuse or exploitation and would like to understand your options, contact Hutcheon Law for confidential advice.
Contact Us Now To Claim


